Low Anthropology

Think about the last time you saw a billionaire on social media or read a productivity guru's guide to waking up at 4 a.m. and "crushing it" with their life hacks for ultimate productivity (yuck). These messages are everywhere, whispering that we can be perfect. They tell us that if we just hustle harder, optimise our lives, and believe in our limitless potential, we can achieve anything.

David Zahl

In today's Western society, there's a dominant way of thinking which writer David Zahl calls a "high anthropology." It presents an inflated and overly optimistic view of what it means to be human. This perspective champions the belief that we are naturally good and should be defined by our achievements.

This narrative suggests that the only limitations we face are the ones we put on ourselves. It creates a sense of boundless capability and measures a person's worth by their greatest accomplishments. It also promotes the idea that we are completely free agents—that all outcomes result from personal choices, while ignoring or downplaying the darker aspects of human nature.

Despite seeming positive, having a high anthropology is actually deeply destructive. The constant pressure to be perfect and live up to impossible expectations leads to burnout, anxiety, and feelings of betrayal by our own physical limitations. This mindset creates existential loneliness, as we feel we are "the only ones" who have messed up.

It creates a split identity where a polished public persona hides the messy reality of our inner lives. This leads to deep shame and self-hatred when expectations aren't met. Furthermore, this inflated view of our own moral standing can lead to self-righteousness, intolerance of weakness in others, and divisive politics that make it difficult to extend forgiveness and mercy.

Another Way?

But what if there's another way? What if our weaknesses, failures, and imperfections aren't something to be fixed, but rather a place to find connection, grace, and even joy?

This is the core idea behind what Zahl calls (you guessed it), a "low anthropology".

Low anthropology offers a counterintuitive yet liberating alternative. It provides a more realistic assessment of human nature. This perspective acknowledges that we are fundamentally limited creatures—limited by time, biology, and knowledge—and are naturally conflicted and self-centred.

Instead of viewing these weaknesses as something to be fixed, low anthropology suggests we are actually a place to find connection, grace, and even joy. Accepting our shared brokenness and limitations fosters humility, empathy, and deep human connection. We see this in our ability to laugh at our shared mistakes and shortcomings. It brings a sigh of relief, allowing people to be honest about their struggles without feeling uniquely broken.

Faith Implications

High anthropology can be particularly damaging to faith, as it often turns Christianity into a boot camp or sin management program. Within church settings, it can create unrealistic expectations, imposing increasingly demanding religious ideals. This results in shame, self-hatred, and religious burnout. It can also lead to a distorted view of God, who becomes merely a helper or guiding force rather than a true saviour. The struggle to achieve righteousness through personal effort can foster anger and self-righteousness, making us more judgmental and hostile when our efforts are challenged or when others fail.

In stark contrast, low anthropology becomes the foundation of healthy faith. It serves as a modern way of talking about theological concepts like "original sin" and "total depravity," which highlight human self-centeredness and our inherited tendency to work against our own flourishing. It also aligns with Martin Luther's concept of the "bondage of the will," acknowledging that our willpower is extremely limited when it comes to matters of the heart.

As Zahl's father famously stated, "the lower your anthropology, the higher your Christology will be." This means that a realistic view of human brokenness leads to greater reliance on God's grace and a deeper understanding that salvation and transformation come from divine intervention, not human effort.

"The lower your anthropology, the higher your Christology will be."

This framework centres on the distinction between law and gospel. The law acts as a gracious mirror that reveals our human limitations and should humble our high anthropology, leading to a necessary surrender. The gospel, on the other hand, provides the forgiveness of sins needed for deliverance. This is captured by Luther's phrase, "simul justus et peccator," meaning "simultaneously justified and sinful." It highlights that Christians remain the same people in many ways after conversion, still wrestling with limitations but now within a relationship defined by God's grace.

Low anthropology reframes sanctification (spiritual growth) by placing the responsibility on God to do the growing. The Holy Spirit is the true agent of change, with God as the gardener who cultivates the soil of our hearts. This perspective makes faith in God not just compelling but urgent, because it underscores our human need for deliverance, redemption, and sustenance from God.

Fostering Authentic Community and Grace

Low anthropology also fosters genuine community and empathy. We see this clearly in groups like Alcoholics Anonymous, where shared struggles create unity, empathy, and ultimately love. Churches that embrace this view become hospitals for sinners—safe spaces where people can bring their failures and shame and be met with compassion rather than condemnation. The Christian faith, when viewed through this lens, becomes a place to lay down your failures and receive second, third, and fourth chances.

This liberating perspective is also highly relevant for parenting. Many parents, including Christian parents, operate from high anthropology, telling their children they are "special," "perfect," and "can do no wrong." While this seems loving, it can actually create significant problems for a child's faith development. If children are taught they are without fault, they may struggle to understand the Christian concepts of grace and forgiveness.

A more biblically grounded approach is to parent with low anthropology—acknowledging and modelling our own imperfection and praising effort rather than pursuing an impossible quest for perfection. This equips children to navigate a complex world and fosters authentic faith rooted in grace, not performance.

---

In a world obsessed with self-optimisation, low anthropology offers more than just a refreshing alternative: it offers radical freedom. This isn't the hollow promise of endless self-improvement or the exhausting pursuit of perfection. It's the profound liberation that comes from embracing the truth about who we really are.

When we stop pretending to be gods and start living as beloved humans, something beautiful happens. Our limitations become doorways to grace. Our failures become bridges to authentic connection. Our brokenness becomes the very place where divine love meets us most powerfully.

This is a roadmap to freedom—not from our humanity, but through it and into it. In acknowledging our shared frailty, we discover we are not alone in our struggles. In admitting our need, we open ourselves to receive what we could never earn. In surrendering the myth of self-sufficiency, we find ourselves held by something infinitely greater than our own willpower.

Low anthropology doesn't diminish human dignity; it restores it. It reminds us that our worth isn't found in our achievements but in our identity as creatures made for grace, community, and hope that transcends our circumstances.